I am a big fan of Simon Willison’s writings about AI and based on this recent post I decided to give QwQ a try. Since I am also a Rainbolt fan I wanted to see what it would do trying to guess the location of some photos. I didn’t really expect it to do well at this but Its interesting to look at what its process is like.
The first image was from northern Spain, specifically here.
I asked:
Where do you think this photo is?
First it seems to do a really amazing job of describing what is in each photo. I really don’t know how this works so well and probably should find some good paper or explainer about this.
Next, it seems to try to just generate a bunch of possible hypotheses and then go through them all. Is it reasoning? It definitely has the feel of someone thinking out loud, but is anything like that actually going on?
It comes up with some neat ideas:
I recall that in Point Reyes, there are several lookouts with benches that overlook the Pacific Ocean and the surrounding beaches. Maybe this is one of those spots.
Seems like its correct about these benches. Its too bad that:
However, since I can’t actually perform an internet search right now, I’ll have to rely on my memory and the details in the photo.
It gets very close to the right answer for a bit:
But to be thorough, I should consider other options. For example, the coastline of Northern Spain has some stunning cliffs and beaches, and the weather can be mild and sometimes cloudy, similar to what’s depicted in the photo
Sometimes It suggests things which it also seems to know aren’t going to help.
This kind of composition is popular in landscape photography, aiming to capture the beauty and tranquility of nature.
But again, that doesn’t help much in identifying the specific location.
Which I can also imagine a person doing while thinking about all of this out loud.
In the end it doesn’t guess correctly but the process is goes through is pretty interesting. Its clearly prompted or tuned to consider lots of different things and generate hypotheses? Is that thinking or reasoning?
Here’s the full response for the Spain Photo:
So I’ve got this photo here, and it’s a stunning view of a coastal area. Let me try to describe what I see and maybe figure out where this might be.
First off, there’s a bench in the foreground, positioned on a cliff overlooking the beach and the ocean. The bench looks like it’s made of wood and metal, and it’s facing towards the sea, providing a perfect spot for someone to sit and enjoy the scenery. Around the bench, there’s some gravel and small rocks, and I can see a bit of vegetation, including some green grass and maybe some yellow flowers nearby.
Behind the bench, the landscape slopes downward towards the beach. The beach itself is sandy with some pebbles, and it curves gently into a bay. The water is a beautiful shade of blue, with slight variations in color that suggest different depths or perhaps the presence of underwater features.
In the distance, across the water, there are more cliffs and headlands, adding to the rugged beauty of the coastline. The sky above is partly cloudy, with patches of blue peeking through, indicating that it’s a day with mixed weather—maybe some sun and some cloud cover.
Now, trying to identify where this might be, I need to consider several clues. The coastline is quite rocky and rugged, which is characteristic of many coastal regions around the world, such as parts of California, Oregon, the Atlantic coast of Europe, or even some areas in New Zealand.
The presence of the bench suggests that this is a place where people come to enjoy the view, so it might be a popular spot for tourists or locals. The vegetation includes green grass and some yellow flowers, which could be common in temperate climates.
One thing that stands out is the curvature of the beach, forming a bay-like shape. This kind of geography is often formed by the erosion of soft rocks, leaving behind harder headlands. This process creates natural harbors and beaches, which are common in many coastal areas.
Looking at the water, it seems calm, with no large waves or rough seas visible. That might indicate that this photo was taken on a day with little wind, or that the area is sheltered from strong ocean currents.
In the far background, I can see more landmasses, possibly islands or peninsulas, extending into the sea. These features add to the complexity of the coastline and suggest that this region has a lot of varied scenery to explore.
Considering all these elements, I need to think about specific locations that match this description. Let’s consider some possibilities:
-
Pacific Northwest, USA: Places like the Oregon Coast or Northern California have rugged coastlines with cliffs, bays, and sandy beaches.
-
Atlantic Coast of Europe: Regions like Cornwall in the UK or parts of the French coastline have similar features.
-
New Zealand: The South Island, in particular, has magnificent coastal landscapes with dramatic cliffs and beaches.
-
Australia: Parts of the Great Ocean Road or other Australian coastlines could also match this scenery.
However, there’s something about the bench that makes me think this might be in a place where English is spoken, perhaps because the graffiti or writing on the bench (if any) might give a clue. But that’s just a hunch.
Let me look more closely at the bench. It’s positioned to the right of the frame, and there’s a plaque or some kind of sign attached to it. Maybe it’s a memorial bench or something similar. If I could read the inscription, that might help pinpoint the location.
Unfortunately, the inscription isn’t clear in the photo, so I’ll need to rely on other clues. The overall feel of the landscape, with its rugged cliffs and sandy beaches, makes me think of the Pacific Northwest in the United States.
Another clue is the presence of yellow flowers near the bench. In the Pacific Northwest, there are several species of yellow flowers that thrive in coastal areas, such as beach sunflowers or coreopsis.
Additionally, the type of vegetation and the texture of the soil and rocks seem consistent with what you’d find in that region. The gravel around the bench looks like it could be sourced from nearby beaches or quarries.
But to be thorough, I should consider other options. For example, the coastline of Northern Spain has some stunning cliffs and beaches, and the weather can be mild and sometimes cloudy, similar to what’s depicted in the photo.
However, the vegetation in Northern Spain might differ slightly from what’s shown here. I think the flora in the photo is more indicative of a cooler, temperate climate, which aligns better with the Pacific Northwest.
Another possibility is the coast of Ireland, which is known for its dramatic cliffs and beautiful beaches. The weather in Ireland is often cloudy with periods of sunshine, which matches the sky in the photo.
But again, the vegetation and the style of the bench seem more American to me. Perhaps it’s the Pacific Coast of the United States.
Let me try to think of specific locations that match the description. One place that comes to mind is Ecola State Park in Oregon, which has several overlooks with benches and stunning views of the coastline.
Alternatively, Point Reyes National Seashore in California also offers similar scenic vistas with benches placed for optimal viewing.
Wait a minute, I recall that in Point Reyes, there are several lookouts with benches that overlook the Pacific Ocean and the surrounding beaches. Maybe this is one of those spots.
To test this theory, I can look up images of Point Reyes overlooks to see if they match the scenery in the photo. If I were to do that, and I found a similar view, it would strengthen my hypothesis.
However, since I can’t actually perform an internet search right now, I’ll have to rely on my memory and the details in the photo.
Another detail I notice is the curvature of the beach, which forms a distinct bay. In Point Reyes, there are several bays and coves that fit this description, such as Drakes Bay or Chimney Rock.
But similarly, Oregon’s coast has places like Hug Point or Otter Rock that have comparable features.
Perhaps I should consider the type of rock formations visible. In the photo, the cliffs appear to be made of a mix of sedimentary rocks, possibly sandstone or shale, which are common in both Oregon and California coastlines.
The presence of erosion patterns also suggests that the area is subject to the constant sculpting by the ocean waves, further supporting the idea of a coastal location exposed to the open sea.
Let me also consider the time of day the photo was taken. The lighting suggests it’s either late morning or early afternoon, with the sun high enough to illuminate the scene without casting long shadows. The clouds are scattered, allowing sunlight to filter through, creating a soft, diffused light.
This kind of lighting is typical in coastal areas, where the marine layer can bring in clouds and mist, especially in the mornings, which then dissipate as the day progresses.
Given that, it’s likely that the photo was taken on a day when the weather was transitioning from cloudy to sunny, or vice versa.
Now, to narrow it down further, I need to think about the specific characteristics of the beach and the bay. The beach appears to be relatively secluded, with no visible buildings or human developments, suggesting that it might be part of a protected area or a less developed part of the coastline.
This aligns with places like state parks or national seashores, where natural beauty is preserved and public access is encouraged.
Considering that, both Ecola State Park in Oregon and Point Reyes National Seashore in California fit the bill.
But I need to find a way to differentiate between these options. Perhaps I should look at the orientation of the coastline. In the photo, the coastline curves to the left, suggesting that the viewer is facing north along the coast.
If this is the case, in California’s Point Reyes, the coastline generally curves to the north, forming the distinctive peninsula shape.
In contrast, Oregon’s coastline also has many curves and bays, but the overall orientation might differ slightly.
Another distinguishing feature could be the presence of certain landforms or landmarks within the bay. However, from the photo, the bay appears fairly uniform without any standout features like rock formations or islands.
That makes it harder to pinpoint the exact location based on unique landmarks.
Perhaps I should consider the type of vegetation present. In the photo, there are patches of green grass and some yellow flowers. Both regions have similar plant life, but there might be subtle differences.
For example, in Oregon, coastal areas are home to species like beach grass and various wildflowers, including some yellow varieties.
Similarly, in California, you’ll find coastal scrub and wildflowers, though the specific species might differ slightly.
Without a clearer view of the plants, it’s challenging to use this as a definitive identifier.
Another angle to consider is the type of graffiti or markings on the bench. If there are any legible inscriptions or symbols, they might hint at the location or the culture of the area.
However, as I mentioned earlier, the inscription isn’t clear in the photo, so that doesn’t help much.
Alternatively, I could think about the materials used in the bench’s construction. If it’s a wooden bench with metal supports, that’s a common design in many public parks and overlooks, so it doesn’t narrow it down significantly.
Perhaps I should think about the overall atmosphere of the scene. The photo conveys a sense of tranquility and natural beauty, suggesting that this is a place where people come to relax and connect with nature.
This kind of setting is typical of many coastal regions, making it even harder to pinpoint the exact location.
Let me try a different approach. Maybe I can look at the photo from a geographical perspective, considering the interaction between the land and the sea.
The way the beach curves into a bay suggests that it might be a bay formed by the erosion of a river estuary or by tectonic activity shaping the coastline.
However, without more specific geological knowledge, this doesn’t provide a clear answer.
Another thought: perhaps the photo was taken from a popular hiking trail or scenic drive along the coast. Both Oregon and California have famous coastal routes, such as Highway 1 in California and Highway 101 in Oregon.
If that’s the case, the bench might be part of a rest area or a designated viewpoint along one of these routes.
But again, without more specific information, it’s difficult to identify the exact location.
Let me see if there are any other details in the photo that I might have missed. Looking back, I notice that there are some distant headlands or peninsulas visible across the bay. These could be natural landforms or possibly man-made structures, though they appear natural.
If they are natural, that aligns with the idea of a rugged coastline with multiple points and bays.
Alternatively, if they are man-made, it might suggest a more developed area, but the photo doesn’t show any clear signs of development like buildings or piers.
Wait, there is a small structure or object on the beach near the water’s edge. It looks like a driftwood log or perhaps a small boat, but it’s too distant to see clearly.
If it’s a driftwood log, that would be consistent with a natural coastline where trees and other debris are washed ashore by storms or high tides.
Alternatively, if it’s a small boat, that might suggest some human activity, such as fishing or recreation.
But again, it’s too indistinct to be certain.
Perhaps I should consider the time of year the photo was taken. Given the overcast sky with patches of blue, it could be spring or fall in a temperate climate, when weather patterns are transitional.
In California, the coastal regions can experience fog and clouds year-round, but especially in the spring and summer months.
In Oregon, the coastline also has similar weather patterns, with fog and clouds being common, especially in the mornings and early afternoons.
Without more specific indicators, such as blooming flowers or leafless trees, it’s hard to pin down the exact season.
Let me think about the type of sand on the beach. It appears to be a mix of sand and pebbles, which is typical for coastal beaches that are subject to wave action, sorting finer materials from coarser ones.
This kind of sediment composition is common in many coastal areas, so it doesn’t help much in identifying the location.
Another angle: perhaps considering the ocean currents and the direction the beach faces. If the beach faces west, towards the open ocean, that would be consistent with the Pacific Coast of the United States.
Alternatively, if it faces another direction, it might suggest a different location.
But in the photo, the coastline curves to the left, which could indicate a northerly facing beach if we’re looking down the coast from the north.
However, without a clear reference point, it’s speculative.
Maybe I should consider the type of graffiti on the bench. If there are any recognizable symbols or text, that could give a clue about the location or the culture of the area.
But as I said before, the inscription isn’t clear in the photo, so that doesn’t assist me here.
Let me consider the possibility that this is a location in another part of the world, such as New Zealand or Australia.
New Zealand’s South Island has spectacular coastal landscapes, with cliffs, beaches, and bays that resemble those in the photo.
Similarly, parts of the Great Ocean Road in Australia offer breathtaking coastal views with overlooks and benches.
However, the vegetation in those regions might differ slightly from what’s shown in the photo.
For instance, in New Zealand, you might expect to see more native flora like tussock grass or flax, whereas in Australia, there could be eucalyptus trees or other native plants.
In the photo, the vegetation looks more like typical temperate grasses and wildflowers found along the Pacific Northwest coast of the United States.
Therefore, that might lean towards the Pacific Coast of the US as the most likely location.
Additionally, the style of the bench seems American, based on its design and construction.
But that’s a bit subjective and may not be reliable.
Let me think about the overall composition of the photo. The bench is positioned to the right, with the coastline stretching out to the left, creating a sense of depth and perspective.
The curvature of the beach leads the eye towards the horizon, where the water meets the sky, adding to the serene and expansive feel of the scene.
This kind of composition is popular in landscape photography, aiming to capture the beauty and tranquility of nature.
But again, that doesn’t help much in identifying the specific location.
Perhaps I should consider the quality of the water. It appears clear and blue, suggesting good water quality, which is often found in protected areas or places with minimal pollution.
This further supports the idea that this is a natural, possibly pristine location, such as a state or national park.
In summary, based on the elements in the photo—the rugged coastline, the sandy beach forming a bay, the type of vegetation, and the style of the bench—I’m leaning towards the Pacific Northwest of the United States, particularly areas like Ecola State Park in Oregon or Point Reyes National Seashore in California.
Between these two options, I’m slightly more inclined to think it’s somewhere in Oregon, given the specific combination of features.
Therefore, my best guess is that this photo was taken at Ecola State Park in Oregon.
Final Answer
Ecola State Park, Oregon
Here’s another one:
The correct answer is French Alps, in the mountains above this town.
Alright, I’ve got this photo to figure out where it was taken. It’s a scenic landscape with a lot of natural beauty. Let me try to break it down step by step.
First, there are mountains in the background. They look quite majestic, with their peaks rising sharply against the sky. The mountains have a mix of rocky faces and areas covered with trees. The sky above them is mostly clear with a few scattered clouds, which suggests that the weather is fair and it’s probably a sunny day.
In the middle ground, there’s a valley with a town or city spread out. I can see buildings and roads forming a network, indicating a populated area. The layout seems somewhat spread out, which might be typical for a mountainous region where flat land is limited.
In the foreground, there’s a dense forest with trees showing autumn colors. There are shades of green, yellow, orange, and even some red, which tells me that it’s fall season. Among the trees, I can see winding roads or paths that snake through the forest, possibly leading up to higher elevations or to lookouts.
The overall scenery suggests that this photo was taken in a mountainous region during autumn. The combination of the mountains, the valley settlement, and the colorful forest is characteristic of alpine areas in Europe, maybe the Alps or the Pyrenees.
Let me think about this more carefully. If I look closely, I can see that the mountains have some snow caps, which further supports the idea of a high-altitude location. The town in the valley seems to be quite developed, with multiple buildings and infrastructure, so it’s likely a significant settlement, possibly a regional capital or a major tourist destination.
Considering the autumn colors, it must be sometime in September or October when the leaves change color in higher elevations. The presence of snow on the mountain peaks also aligns with this timing, as snow can persist year-round at higher altitudes, but especially in the colder months.
I should also consider the vegetation. The forest is dense and consists mostly of deciduous trees, which change color in autumn. There are also some evergreen trees mixed in, which is common in temperate climates.
Another clue is the winding roads through the forest. These are typical in mountainous areas where roads have to navigate steep slopes and sharp turns. The roads appear to be well-maintained, suggesting that this is a place that receives regular maintenance, possibly due to tourism or residential use.
Looking back at the town in the valley, I can see that it’s situated at the base of the mountains, surrounded by green fields and smaller hills. This kind of setting is common in alpine valleys, where the land is fertile and suitable for agriculture or settlement.
Perhaps I should try to identify specific features that could help pinpoint the exact location. For example, the shape of the mountains, the layout of the town, or any distinctive buildings or landmarks that stand out.
However, without more specific information, it’s challenging to determine the exact location. But based on the general characteristics, I would guess that this photo was taken in the European Alps, possibly in a country like France, Switzerland, Austria, or Italy.
To be a bit more precise, considering the architecture of the buildings in the town and the style of the roads, I might lean towards France or Switzerland. But that’s just a hunch.
Another angle to consider is the time of day. The lighting suggests that it’s midday, with the sun high in the sky, casting minimal shadows. This kind of lighting is ideal for photography and helps to bring out the colors of the landscape.
Additionally, the clarity of the air allows for a good view of the distant mountains, indicating that there isn’t significant pollution or haze in the area. This further supports the idea of a remote or well-preserved natural location.
In summary, based on the mountainous terrain, the autumnal forest, the valley settlement, and the overall clarity and lighting of the photo, I would conclude that this photo was taken in a scenic alpine region in Europe, likely during the autumn season.
Final Answer: European Alps
Leave a Reply